Book Study: Open Middle Math

Introduction: What Does an Open Middle Classroom Look Like?

Imagine walking into a math classroom where students are leaning in, not just toward their work, but toward each other, actively discussing strategies and debating ideas. That’s the energy of an Open Middle classroom. Here, math isn’t about quickly filling in blanks; it’s about curiosity, exploration, and growth. Students aren’t afraid to make mistakes because they understand that struggle is part of the process.

Creating this kind of learning environment takes intention. It starts with the problems we choose and the culture we nurture. Students are encouraged to engage deeply with concepts instead of focusing on getting the right answer quickly. As Robert Kaplinsky writes, “Being fast at math is not the same as being good at math.” In Open Middle classrooms, students develop perseverance and confidence. They become the kind of thinkers who don't just solve problems; they understand them.

Chapter One: How Will These Problems Help Me?

Open Middle problems are designed to surface student thinking. Rather than checking if a student can follow a procedure, these problems show how a student thinks about math. That makes them powerful tools for formative assessment. They also build student agency by allowing learners to take ownership of their solutions and justify their reasoning.

For teachers, this means a shift in focus, from delivering information to facilitating thinking. These problems encourage a deeper level of engagement and help teachers address misconceptions as they emerge. Kaplinsky notes, “Open Middle problems help students develop a growth mindset by pushing them to persevere.” The classroom becomes a lab of ideas where students learn to value the process as much as the outcome.

Chapter Two: How Are Open Middle Problems Different?

These problems stand apart from traditional math tasks. Most textbook problems have a closed beginning, middle, and end. There is one correct answer and one accepted way to get there. Open Middle problems flip that structure: the beginning and end may be fixed, but there are many paths to reach the solution.

This flexibility allows students to experiment with strategies and think outside the box. They can approach problems from multiple angles and compare outcomes. That naturally leads to rich classroom conversations and deeper understanding. As Kaplinsky explains, “They’re not just doing math; they’re thinking mathematically.” For many students, especially those who’ve felt boxed in by traditional methods, Open Middle problems offer a fresh and inviting challenge.

Chapter Three: What Do We Need to Do Before Using a Problem with Students?

Success with Open Middle problems starts with thoughtful planning. It’s essential to choose problems that are challenging but accessible. Consider your students’ prior knowledge and anticipate different strategies they might use. A good problem should invite productive struggle without being overwhelming.

Just as important is setting the right tone. Make it clear that mistakes are not just acceptable; they’re expected and valuable. When students know they’re in a safe space to take risks, they’re more willing to engage deeply. Kaplinsky suggests establishing routines that support persistence and reflection. That foundation helps students not just “try it once and give up,” but also develop the stamina to stick with challenging problems.

Chapter Four: How Do We Use a Problem with Students?

Start by presenting the problem with as little frontloading as possible. Let students grapple with it. Then, step back, not to disengage but to observe and support. Your role shifts to facilitator: asking questions, prompting reflection, and guiding discussions that stimulate student thinking.

Encourage collaboration and dialogue. As students explore solutions, highlight different strategies and discuss the merits of each. Ask questions like, “Why do you think that works?” or “Can anyone solve it a different way?” Kaplinsky emphasizes the importance of closing the problem with a meaningful debrief. This is your chance to bring the class together, connect ideas, and solidify learning in a way that empowers students to carry those insights forward.

Chapter Five: Where Can I Get More Open Middle Problems?

You don’t have to start from scratch. The Open Middle website offers a rich library of problems organized by grade and standard. These can be easily integrated into your lessons or adapted to fit your classroom needs better.

But don’t stop there. Kaplinsky encourages teachers to create their own. “If you know how to turn a worksheet problem into an Open Middle problem, you’ll never run out of rich tasks.” Look for textbook problems with rigid procedures and consider how you might open them up: change the numbers, set constraints, or flip the goal. This becomes a creative and rewarding part of your instructional planning with practice.

Chapter Six: What Comes Next?

Collaborate with colleagues, tweak problems to suit your students better, and look for ways to deepen mathematical thinking. Open Middle problems allow learners to shine in ways that traditional instruction often doesn’t. With time and support, they’ll grow into confident problem solvers who aren’t just prepared for tests. As Kaplinsky puts it, “When students persevere through challenging problems, they learn they are capable of more than they thought.” That’s the kind of learning that sticks.

BUY NOW:  https://link.robertkaplinsky.com/openmiddle

Follow Robert on Social Media: